The Best Toaster for Your Airbnb or Vacation Rental in 2023

If you’ve decided to expand your kitchen amenities and the time has come to buy a toaster, our recommendations for the best toaster for Airbnb can help you choose the right one!

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links.

Get more inventory ideas in our Airbnb Host Checklist

Every appliance that makes your guests’ stay enjoyable is more than appreciated. A toaster is one of those items that isn’t among the vacation rental necessities but can be an efficient and attractive addition to your short-term rental.

We dove deep into the search for the best toaster for Airbnb to see which one both guests and owners find to be most efficient. After reading reviews, talking to vacation rental owners, and considering our own experiences, we can safely say that the winner is the Oster 2-Slice Toaster.

Why Get a Toaster for Your Airbnb?

Guests love when Airbnb owners go the extra mile to make their guests feel at home. Providing your guests with a toaster is one of those moves your guests will appreciate.

If you don’t have a full kitchen but rather a kitchenette, a fridge, microwave, electric kettle, and a toaster will be enough for your guests to make breakfast or have brunch at your rental.

On the other hand, if your aim is to entice guests to stay longer or to attract those who are looking for a rental that accommodates eating in, you want to set up a full kitchen. This is when a toaster is more of a necessity on a vacation rental kitchen checklist. According to the International Housewares Association, 80 percent of American households have toasters, so guests will expect it if in your listing you advertise a fully equipped kitchen. 

Factors to Consider When Buying a Toaster for Your Airbnb

If you want a toaster that will suit the needs of your guests and yourself as a property owner, we suggest that you consider these factors before deciding which toaster you’ll buy:

Toaster vs Toaster Oven  – Toasters are more than enough for most short-term rentals, especially if you already have a full-size oven. With a defrost feature and the option to toast bagels, your guests can make many tasty meals. 

Toaster ovens can come in handy if you don’t have an oven and you have the type of guests who like to cook in the rental. With a toaster oven, they’ll be able to bake, broil, roast, reheat, and more. 

However, the reason why Airbnb owners prefer toasters is safety. It’s easy to accidentally leave a toaster oven’s bake setting turned on, which can be a liability. If you don’t want to have an insurance company on speed dial, the best toaster oven for Airbnb is the one that has an auto shut-off feature. 

Customizable – Guests have different tastes, so look for a toaster that has options to customize the toasting. Some of the options that come in handy are setting the width of the slice of bread, toast times, and a wide range of browning—so guests can make very light to very dark toast, depending on their preference.

Easy to Clean – Cleaning appliances is such a tedious job, so you want to make sure that you make it as quick as possible. When it comes to cleaning a toaster, narrow your search to those which have a removable crumb tray.

Slot Size – A two-slice toaster is the most common option. However, if your rental accommodates big groups of guests, you may also consider buying a four-slice model. It is bulkier and takes up more space in the kitchen, but it will also save time. 

Warranty – A warranty can give you peace of mind in case the toaster needs repairing. If anything happens with the toaster that is a manufacturer’s error, you’ll get your toaster fixed free of charge—avoiding unexpected costs is always a plus!

The Best Toaster for Airbnb and Vacation Rentals

After reviewing many different toasters, we’ve concluded that the Oster 2-Slice Toaster is the best one for short-term rentals. It ticks all the boxes and promises to last.

Oster 2-Slice Toaster

Here are a few specifics that we love about this toaster:

Advanced Toast Technology – This toaster is designed with auto-adjusting bread guides and Advanced Toast Technology which ensure consistent toasting even after long-term use. 

Durable Material – The toaster is made of stainless steel—the most durable material when it comes to appliances. Even if a guest drops it, it will survive the fall. 

Extra-Wide Slots – Wider slots will allow your guests to toast any kind of bread, from regular toast to artisanal bread.

Shade Setting – With 7 toast shades, your guests can easily customize the range of browning to their liking.

Automatic Toasting Time – To take the guesswork out of toasting, there are automatic toasting times for bagels, pastries, and even frozen goods, guaranteeing perfect results. 

Removable Crumb Tray – Just take out the tray, throw out the crumbs, put the tray back, and that’s it! 

Stylish Design – Besides the classic black, there’s also a modern purple version if you want to add a splash of color to your kitchen. 

1-Year Warranty – The icing on the cake is a one-year warranty. If the toaster fails to perform its duties properly, you can return it and get your money back. 

Other Airbnb Toaster Alternatives

We’ve picked out a couple of alternatives if you’re considering a 4-slice toaster, or if you want to make a comparison before finalizing your decision. In addition to our top pick, we also like the Cuisinart 4-Slice Compact Toaster and the Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster.

The Cuisinart CPT-142BK Toaster comes in a 2-slice and a 4-slice version. It was tested and recommended by the New York Times, and on top of that, it has thousands of reviews and a stellar rating on Amazon. 

This toaster has all the features you want in an Airbnb toaster—multiple toasting functions (toast, bagel, defrost, and reheat), a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning, and 7 toast shades. There’s a 3-year warranty which is also pretty great. The only downside is that it is made out of plastic—a much less durable material compared to stainless steel.

This second contender comes from a trusted brand we’ve also recommended for the best coffee maker, and that is Hamilton Beach. The Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster is great for thicker bread and bagels because of its extra-wide slots. We love that it has the toast boost feature, so lifting smaller pieces of bread will be super easy.

There’s also a 4-slice version of Hamilton Beach’s Extra Wide Slot Toaster. What can be a drawback for some is that it only has 2 settings—bagel and defrost. 

Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for an affordable and durable toaster that is suitable for a variety of bread, your best bet is to buy the Oster 2-Slice Toaster. While we’re also impressed with its contenders, the Oster toaster did the best job at fulfilling all of the criteria without any downsides.