Lodgify vs Hostfully – Which Vacation Rental Software Is Best? [2023]

With numerous vacation rental management platforms available, it’s essential to carefully consider which platform will best meet your needs. Among the popular choices in the industry, Lodgify and Hostfully often come into the spotlight, so let’s find out what they have to offer.

In this comprehensive Lodgify vs Hostfully comparison, we’ll take into account crucial factors such as features, pricing, and customer support. We’ll also take our investigation one step further and provide you with suitable alternatives to further broaden your range of options.

Lodgify vs Hostfully: An Overview

Lodgify is a software designed to centralize property management. Its user-friendly channel manager, website builder for direct bookings, task management features, robust reporting and accounting features, and seamless integrations make this platform an end-to-end solution for property owners and managers. For a full analysis of Lodgify’s offerings, refer to our review. 

Hostfully’s all-in-one platform was created to simplify and streamline vacation rental management. With this intuitive software, you can automate bookings across channels, accept payments, manage expenses, unify guest communication, and integrate numerous popular apps. Additionally, Hostfully can automate repetitive tasks with reminders, automatic follow-ups, and notifications. 

Pricing

Winner: Lodgify

Lodgify caters to different property management needs with three pricing tiers. The first tier starts at $17/month ($13/month when paid annually) for a single property, accompanied by a 1.9% booking fee. To bypass the fee, you can choose the Professional plan, available at $48/month. With each plan, you gain access to more features. Additionally, Lodgify offers volume discounts, ensuring that the cost per property decreases as your property portfolio grows. 

If you wish to get first-hand experience with Lodgify before you make a financial commitment, you can sign up for a 7-day free trial.

Hostfully is the pricier solution, starting at $109/month for managing up to 4 properties. The pricing structure is three-tiered, and each tier unlocks more features. There’s also a one-time implementation fee of $600. In addition to that, there are processing fees for Stripe and Paypal (for more details about the fee, get in touch with Hostfully’s sales reps). If you opt for an annual subscription, you get a 10% discount, and the implementation fee will be reduced to $300. To lower the price even more, use the code EGNTNJ494 for $100 off. 

Hostfully lacks a free trial, but it provides a one-on-one personalized software demo upon request. 

Considering that Lodgify is more affordable, doesn’t have an implementation fee, and offers a free trial, Lodgify wins this round. 

Features

Winner: Tie

Lodgify and Hostfully have a similar set of features, and both software can serve as an all-in-one software solution for managing properties. There is no clear winner, but there are subtle distinctions between the two that may influence your preference.

One distinction is that Lodgify allows you to create custom pages for your direct bookings website, while with Hostfully, you can simply customize the pre-built site. Lodgify also has an incredible variety of stunning website templates, and its website builder is probably the best on the market.

Hostfully supports more integrations, including marketing automation tools like MailChimp and StayFi, guidebook integration which allows you to create guidebooks for guests using data from the platform, and much more. This platform also provides you with detailed performance insights, including agent performance, daily property performance, and other useful data. 

Even though Lodgify integrates with DocuSign for digital signatures, Hostfully has a built-in feature that captures digital signatures for rental agreements, terms and conditions, or security deposits, regardless of the booking channel.

One thing we should highlight regarding integrations is that both platforms integrate with Zapier, so this expands your integration options.

Customer Support

Winner: Tie

The customer service rating and reviews are comparable for these two platforms, as the differences are minimal. Lodgify and Hostfully’s users have shared mainly positive experiences, with only a handful of them being negative. However, Lodgify does have a significantly higher number of reviews on Capterra.

Conclusion – Lodgify or Hostfully?

Lodgify and Hostfully are two feature-rich and intuitive platforms. They are both user-friendly, so you’ll be able to navigate through the platforms and put the features to use in no time. Since neither of the two stand out as a clear choice, let’s look once more at their strengths.

Lodgify is a more budget-friendly solution, so it’s more suitable for small to medium businesses. The stunning website templates ensure that you create a beautiful site to entice more customers. You can also take advantage of the free trial to test out the platform and its features.

If you manage over 10 properties and you prioritize extensive reporting and numerous integrations, Hostfully may be your preferred program. This comprehensive software can bring together everything from marketing automation to turnover management thanks to its powerful integrations. 

Alternatives to Lodgify and Hostfully

If you’re seeking a robust software alternative similar to Lodgify and Hostfully, we recommend that you check out Uplisting. 

Uplisting stands out as our top choice for vacation rental management software due to its impressive feature set, exceptional customer support, and consistent efforts to expand its functionalities and improve this already comprehensive platform. 

Compare vacation rental software options with our spreadsheet.

View spreadsheet

Some other sought-after management platforms that we would recommend are Guesty, HostHub, OwnerRez, and Smoobu.

For an extensive list of Lodgify’s alternatives, refer to our in-depth comparison. 

Written by The Floorspace Team

This article was written as a collaborative effort by multiple members of the Floorspace team. We're a group of internet marketers and designers, with a wide range of experience marketing and managing short-term rentals.